Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... Jefferson's Great Gamble: The Remarkable Story of Jefferson, Napoleon and the Men Behind the Louisiana Purchase (edition 2003)by Charles CeramiI really enjoyed this look at the background and machinations behind the Louisiana Purchase. My knowledge had been limited to Thomas Jefferson's part in it, so I was intrigued by Madison and Monroe's parts in the purchase [and background leading to it] and the significant roles of people whose involvements are not well known much less suspected. Detailed research and interesting persons explored in detail. There's a lot wrong with this book as a work of history. Cerami speculates a lot, especially in the first half, about the thoughts and feelings of his subjects--speculation based upon his impressions of them which he has gleaned from other biographies. The endnotes are a complete disaster--I jumped back many times to find sources, and was often left hanging. The bibliography consists almost entirely of biographies of the main historical giants, and a general reference to "Letters", and very few primary sources. Its perspective is too skewed--Napoleon is a shadowy colossus across the sea, Talleyrand a diplomatic genius whose flaws (Cerami suggests) we must overlook to appreciate his character, while Jefferson and Madison are the dynamic duo. Jefferson actually comes off a little strange, threatening war until du Pont suggests the purchase. This skew goes so far, at one point, as to refer to America's budding State Department as "our". It is a very readable account of an important event, but the breezy style goes too far, e.g. referring to the "Jefferson-Madison Theatrical Society". This book or one like it would be an interesting read prior to a bio of Aaron Burr. At one point Madison tries to convince Pichon that France should not provoke the US to expand into the territory--"It would surely give birth to a second American state, certain to clash with the Eastern part..." (No endnote.) |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)973.46History and Geography North America United States Constitutional period (1789-1809) Thomas Jefferson (4 Mar. 1801-4 Mar. 1809)LC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
Cerami speculates a lot, especially in the first half, about the thoughts and feelings of his subjects--speculation based upon his impressions of them which he has gleaned from other biographies.
The endnotes are a complete disaster--I jumped back many times to find sources, and was often left hanging. The bibliography consists almost entirely of biographies of the main historical giants, and a general reference to "Letters", and very few primary sources. Its perspective is too skewed--Napoleon is a shadowy colossus across the sea, Talleyrand a diplomatic genius whose flaws (Cerami suggests) we must overlook to appreciate his character, while Jefferson and Madison are the dynamic duo. Jefferson actually comes off a little strange, threatening war until du Pont suggests the purchase. This skew goes so far, at one point, as to refer to America's budding State Department as "our".
It is a very readable account of an important event, but the breezy style goes too far, e.g. referring to the "Jefferson-Madison Theatrical Society".
This book or one like it would be an interesting read prior to a bio of Aaron Burr. At one point Madison tries to convince Pichon that France should not provoke the US to expand into the territory--"It would surely give birth to a second American state, certain to clash with the Eastern part..." (No endnote.) ( )