 | Canada. Parliament. Senate - Canada - 1916 - 630 pages
...CHOQUETTE— On the point of order I refer to May at page 574 where I find the following: That in all aid given to the King by the Commons the rate or tax ought not to be altered by the law. This does not touch the rate or tax. The Government are entitled to take the money and do what... | |
 | Thomas Erskine May - Great Britain - 1917 - 960 pages
...upon the subjects of the Crown (see p. 470) advanced this claim still further in 1071 by resolving, " That in all aids given to the king by the Commons,...the rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords ; " and, on the 3rd July, 1678, by a second resolution, " That all aids and supplies, and aids to his... | |
 | Canada. Parliament. Senate - Canada - 1918 - 740 pages
...the Lords House which lays any charge or tax upon any of the Commons." In 1671 the Commons affirmed that "in all aids given to the King by the Commons...rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords." In 1678 the Commons resolved: "That all aids and supplies and aids xo His Majesty in Parliament are... | |
 | Sir Courtenay Peregrine Ilbert - Cabinet system - 1920 - 280 pages
...asserted, as against the other house, their exclusive right to control taxation. In 1671 they resolved " that in all aids given to the king by the commons,...rate or tax ought not to be altered by the lords." In 1678 they again resolved, in fuller language, " that all aids and supplies, and aids toHis Majesty... | |
 | Great Britain. Parliament - History - 1924 - 546 pages
...halfpeny half farthing, was read the second time ; and debated. Resolved, etc., nemine contradicente, that, in all aids given to the king, by the Commons,...rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords. (CJ, IX. 235.) Apr. 13, HC. Ordered, that it be referred to Mr. Attorney-General, Mr. Coleman, Sir... | |
 | Dudley Julius Medley - Constitutional history - 1925 - 902 pages
...resolutions in the reign (b) amend- of Charles II. In the first they asserted 'that in all ment, 1671. aids given to the king by the Commons, the rate or tax 3 Robertson, ought not to be altered ' :s and they followed this up by an 573. elaborate summary of... | |
 | Sir John Arthur Ransome Marriott - Legislative bodies - 1927 - 274 pages
...resolutions which are the loci classici of the constitutional lawyers. By that of 1671 the Commons affirmed that ' in all aids given to the King by the Commons, the rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords'.3 That of 1678 asserted, ' That all aids and supplies, and aids to His Majesty in Parliament... | |
 | Nineteenth century - 1909 - 1132 pages
...resolutions of the House of Commons passed in 1671 and 1678 respectively. By the first the Commons affirmed ' that in all aids given to the King by the Commons...the rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords ; " by the second, that AH aids and supplies, and aids to his Majesty in Parliament are the sole gift... | |
 | J. P. Kenyon - History - 1986 - 504 pages
...halfpenny half-farthing, was read the second time, and debated. Resolved, &c., nemine contradicente, that in all aids given to the king by the Commons...rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords. [Conference, 20 April 1671] . . . Their Lordships had neither reason nor precedent offered by the Commons... | |
 | Anne Twomey - Constitutional history - 2004 - 966 pages
...purse rests in the Lower House of Westminster-style Parliaments. In 1671 the House of Commons resolved that 'in all aids given to the King by the Commons,...rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords'. On 3 July 1678, the House of Commons passed the following resolution: That all Aids and Supplies, and... | |
| |
Resolved, &c., iiemine contradicente, that in all aids given to the king by the Commons the rate or tax ought not to be altered by the Lords. (ii) 3 July 1678 Resolved, &c., that all aids and supplies, and aids to his Majesty in Parliament, are the sole... 
