REPORTS OP CASES ARGUED AND DETERMINED IN THE Supreme Court of Judicature OP THE STATE OF INDIANA, WITH TABLES OF CASES REPORTED AND CITED, AND STAT- UTES CITED AND CONSTRUED, AND AN INDEX. CHARLES F. REMY, OFFICIAL REPORTER. JOHN W. DONAKER, Assistant Reporter. VOL. 158, CONTAINING CASES DECIDED AT THE NOVEMBER TERM, 1901, AND NOT THE MAY TERM, 1902. INDIANAPOLIS: Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year one thousand nine hundred and three, BY DANIEL E. STORMS, SECRETARY OF THE STATE OF INDIANA, In trust for the benefit of the State of Indiana, in the office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington, D. C. Rec. may 25, 1903. TABLE OF CASES REPORTED IN THIS VOLUME. 87 .706 Allen v. McGee... .465 | Christman, Pease v..... .612 Applegate v. State, ex rel., Citizens St. R. Co., BonBowling .119 ..106 City of Indianapolis, MurBaker, Gifford v.. .339 phy v.. .238 Baltimore, etc., R. Co. v. City of New Albany, Gas Jones Light, etc., Co. v.. ...268 Baltimore, etc., R. Co. V. Cleveland, etc., R. Co., State Reed 25 V. .403 Bennett, Craig v.. 9 Commercial Ins. Co., State, Berghoff, State, ex rel., Drei ex rel., Hart v.. .680 belbiss y. ..349 Cory, Ludwig v... ..582 Berry v. Chicago, etc., R. Cox, Brown V.. ..364 Co. .668 | Craig v. Bennett. 9 Bevilheimer, Kenney v.. .653 Craig, Toy v. .444 Board, etc., v. Gibson. 471 Board, etc., Gross y. 531 Davis Coal Co. v. Polland...607 Board, etc., Swartz v.......141 Ditto, Indiana, etc., R. Co. Board, etc., Turner v. ...166 V. ..669 Board, etc., Weatherhogg v. 14 Dixon v. Poe. 54 Board of Children's Guard Downham v. Holloway. .626 ians, Wilkison V.. 1 Bonham v. Citizens St. R. Eissler v. Hoppel... 82 Co. .106 Elliott, State, ex rel., MinBower, Whittenberger v....673 turn V ..168 Brems v. Sherman... ..300 Erdel, Terre Haute, etc., R. Brooks y. Pittsburgh, etc. R. Co. V. .34 Co. 62 Brown v. Clow. 403 Feirick, Indiana R. Co. V...621 Brown y. Cox.. .364 Fenstermaker v. Holman. 71 Brown v. Sullivan.. .224 | Fish, Pittsburgh, etc., R. Co. V. ..525 Cadwallader, Goodwine v..202 Flint & Walling Mfg. Co., Campbell, Carnahan v.... .226 Marcy Mfg. Co. v. ..173 Carnahan v. Campbell. .226 | Forry, Carver y.. 76 Carpenter, State v.. .368 | Fox, State, ex rel., Geake v..126 Carver v. Forry... 76 Frankel v. Michigan Mut. Central Iron, etc., Co., O'Brien Life Ins. Co... ..304 V. .... .218 Fry, Wray v. 92 Chicago, etc., R. Co., Berry Fulk, Huntington, etc., Assn. .668 V. ..113 Chicago, etc., R. Co. v. Lesh.423 Fulmer, Heywood v. ..658 Chicago, etc., R. Co., Morford v. .494 Gas Light, etc., Co. v. City Chicago, etc., R. Co. v. State, of New Albany.... ..268 ex rel., Zimmerman.. .189 Gibson, Board, etc., V. ...471 v. Gifford v. Baker..... .339 | Machler, Pittsburgh, etc., R. Gillespie, Pittsburgh, etc., R. Co. V... .159 Co. V.. ..454 Magic Packing Co. v. StoneGoodwine v. Cadwallader...202 Ordean Wells Co.... .538 Gross v. Board, etc... .531 | Maitlen, Vernon Ins. Co. v..393 Gustin, Jester v.. .287 | Malott V. State, ex rel., Board, etc... ..678 Hanlin, Osborne & Co. V....325 Marcy Mfg. Co. v. Flint & Hanna v. McLaughlin. .292 Walling Mfg. Co... 173 Harmon v. State... 37 Masters v. Jones.. .647 Hays v. Pugh... .500 McConnell, Horner v. 280 Henning, State v.. .196 McCoy v. Kokomo R., etc., Heywood v. Fulmer. .658 Co.... .662 Hibben v. Smith. ...206 McGee, Allen v..... .465 Holloway, Downham v......626 McLaughlin, Hanna v.. ..292 Holman, Fenstermaker v.... 71 Mellott v. Messmore. .297 Hoover v. Patton.... .524 Merrett v. Ritter. .491 Hoppel, Eissler v.. 82 Messmore, Mellott v. ..297 Horner v. McConnell. ....280 Michigan Mut. Life Ins. Co., Huntington, etc., Assn. v. Frankel v...... .304 Fulk .113 Miller, Lautman v. .382 Miller y. Stephens.. 438 Indiana, etc., Gas Co. v. Miller, Wabash R. Co. V.....174 State, ex rel., Ball... .516 Modern Woodmen v. Noyes.503 Indiana, etc., R. Co. Monroe County Council, Ditto ...669 State, ex rel., Morgan v.... ..102 Indiana R. Co. v. Feirick...621 Morford v. Chicago, etc., R. Indianapolis St. R. Co., Rob- Co. ... ....494 erts V... .634 Murphy v. City of IndianapIndianapolis St. R. Co., olis ..238 Smith v. 425 Indianapolis St. R. Co. v. Tay Noyes, Modern Woodmen v..503 lor .274 International, etc., Assn. V. O'Brien v. Central Iron, etc., Watson .508 .218 O'Brien v. Louer. .211 Jester v. Gustin..... ....287 Oglebay, Todd v. .595 Jones, Baltimore, etc., R. Co. Ohio, etc., Oil Co., Peele v....374 87 Osborne & Co. v. Hanlin....325 Jones, Masters v.. .647 ....380 Kaufman v. Preston.... .361 Patton, Hoover v... .524 Kenney v. Bevilheimer. ....653 Pease v. Christman. .642 Kent v. Sigler.,. ..214 Peele v. Ohio, etc., Oil Co...374 Kerr, State, ex rel., Payne v.155 Pittsburgh, etc., R. Co., Kirkman v. State.. ..156 62 Kline v. Kline... .602 Pittsburgh, etc., R. Co. v. Kokomo R. etc., Co., McCoy Fish ..525 V...... .662 Pittsburgh, etc., R. Co. v. Gillespie .454 Lankford, State, ex rel., Pittsburgh, etc., R. Co. v. Whitaker y.. 34 Machler .159 Lautman v. Miller. ..382 Poe, Dixon v.. 54 Leibold v. Leibold. 60 Polland, Davis Coal Co. V...607 Lesh, Chicago, etc., R. Co. V.423 Preston, Kaufman v.. .361 Louer, O'Brien v.. ..211 Prudential Ins. Oo., Thomas Lowe, Turpie v.. 47 .461 Lowe, Turpie v... .314 Pugh, Hays v.. ..500 Ludwig v. Cory.. .582 V..... V... Recht, Thompson v.........302 | State, ex rel., Lewis v. Smith.543 ..332 Reifers, Rinehardt v. .675 State, Wheeler y. .687 Rinehardt v. Reifers. ..675 Stephens, Miller v. .438 Ritter, Merrett v..... .491 Stone v. Stone... .628 Roberts v. Indianapolis St. Stone-Ordean Wells Co., R. Co,... .634 Magic Packing Co. V......538 Robinson, Soules v.... 97 | Sullivan, Brown V..... .224 Roth v. State, ex rel., Kurtz.242 | Swartz v. Board, etc..... .141 Semon v. State.. 55 Taylor, Indianapolis St. R. Sherman, Brems y.. .300 .274 Shilling v. State, ex rel., Terre Haute, etc., R. Co. v. Board, etc... .185 Erdel .344 Sigler, Kent v.. .214 Thomas V. Prudential Ins. Smith, Hibben v. 206 Co.. .461 Smith v. Indianapolis St. R. Thompson v. Recht. .302 Co. 425 Todd v. Oglebay. .595 Smith, State, ex rel., Lewis v.513 | Toner v. Wagner... .447 Smyth v. State, ex rel.,Braun.332 Town of Fredericksburg v. Soules v. Robinson 97 Wilcoxen .359 State, ex rel., Bowling, Ap- Town of Sullivan, Bell v...199 plegate V.... 119 Toy v. Craig... .444 State, ex rel., Dreibelbiss v. Turner v. Board, etc.. .166 Berghoff .349 Turpie v. Lowe.. 47 State v. Carpenter... .368 Turpie v. Lowe... .314 State, ex rel., Zimmerman, Chicago, etc., R. Co. V....189 Vernon Ins. Co., Maitlen v..393 State v. Cleveland, etc., R. Vink v. Work.... .638 Co. ..706 .380 State, ex rel., Hart v. Commercial Ins. Co...........680 Wabash R. Co. v. Miller.....174 State, ex rel., Minturn v. Elliott .168 Wagner, Toner v..... .447 State, ex rel., Geake v. Fox..126 Watson, International, etc., Assn. V. 37 ..508 State, Harmon v.. State v. Henning.. ..196 Weatherhogg v. Board, etc.. 14 State, ex rel., Ball, Indiana, Weigel, Zimmerman v......370 etc., Gas Co. V....... ..687 Wheeler v. State.... ......516 Whittenberger v. Bower....673 State, ex rel., Payne v. Kerr.155 Wilcoxen, Town of FrederState, Kirkman v. .156 ..359 State, ex rel., Whitaker v. icksburg v.. Lankford 34 Wilkison v. Board of Children's Guardians.. 1 State, ex rel., Board, etc., Ma Wine v. Woods.. .388 lott v...... ..678 .388 State, ex rel., Morgan v. Work, Vink v.. .638 Monroe County Council...,102 92 State, ex rel., Kurtz, Roth v.242 Wray v. 'Fry. State, Semon y... State, ex rel., Board, etc., Zimmerman v. Weigel .....370 Shilling v... ..185 55 |