Page images

specting the concession of seats in parlia. sidered that the measure would tend ment to the Roman Catholics of Ireland.

to attach its objects to government. His general principles are opposed to it; Without proper regulations, he was and the exception, which he admitted in well aware that it would tend only to their favour, was founded on a state of excite their ambition, and encourage things, which not only is gone by, but has hopes of farther advantages. If given been succeeded by one utterly and essentially at variance with it."

to them to be enjoyed as a right, and

not to be forfeited, otherwise than by At a subsequent period, he said, such misconduct as the law of the if amongst our Clergy, (the Roman land would punish, it would have Catholic,) one seditious sermon can be amounted to nothing less than an Estashewn to have been preached, we will blishment. readily admit there is good reason for

* “ Yet such was the measure, which, in continuing the present laws in all their the session of 1825, was actually received force!!”

with favour in the English House of Com. « Could the man who wrote this sen- mons; the bill conferring it had an ascer. tence, and that man, Mr Burke,--had tained passage through that House, and he lived to witness the smallest part of that the Roman Catholics of Ireland were system of deliberate outrage and intimida. brought to regard it, not as a boon for tion, which has been adopted by the whole which it became them to be grateful, but mass of Roman Catholics in Ireland, and, as a mere act of scanty justice which the above all, by their Hierarchy and their Legislature besought them to take in good Priesthood, --could he, I ask, be the advo- part. They had, it is true, shown, from cate and patron of such a cause ? Could the first, no disposition to be satisfied with he give the sanction his honoured name any pecuniary provisions of a less inde. to the demands of those, who avowedly and pendent nature. Dr Doyle had plainly exultingly proclaim their deadliest hate, told the Committees, that he and his bré. their most active unmitigable hostility, to thren would -rather receive nothing from the Church of Ireland, the Protestant Epis- the State, and that certainly, if they recopal Church there established by law ?” ceived at all, it should be on such terms So much for the opinions of Edmund interest in the grant.

only as should give them a vested life

The obsequious Burke. Now, let us attend to those of House of Commons framed their measure William Pitt. Dr Phillpotts has been accordingly; and Mr O'Connell, when remarked by the enemy for his publica- proached by his less judicious associates tion of Mr Pitt's Letter. He has been for having acceded to an expedient which thanked for it by Mr Butler, by the bore the name, if not the semblance, of a Irish orators, by the Edinburgh Review, security to this Protestant Establishand by that high-minded gentleman, ment, justified himself by characterizing plain-spoken politician, consistent po

very truly the prospect of carrying this litical economist, and stanch Tory, Mr

measure as the likelihood of establishing, Huskisson. The letter consists of two

like the Scotch, an Established Church.'» parts. First, an able, brief, and compre- Mr Pitt had, it is plain from his hensive statement of all the reasons language, a very different plan in view which are adduced for granting the such a plan, most probably, says claims of the Roman Catholics. “And our author, as is pursued towards the

I know not,” says Dr Phillpotts,“ that Presbyterian Ministers in Ireland any considerable arguments in favour a regium donum wbich might be withof that measure are there omitted, ex- drawn at any time, but would cercept those which both the king and the tainly never be withdrawn so long as minister would have equally disdained, its objects proved themselves worthy the arguments addressed to the fears of of the bounty of the State. Thirdly, Englishmen.Secondly, of a clearer Mr Pitt thoughtit indispensably necesand fuller statement of the conditions sary to any tolerable plan for remowhich he proposed to annex to the ving the political disabilities of the concession than has before been given Roman Catholics, that the Popish to the public. These conditions are, clergy should be subjected to superinfirst, a continuance of the oaths al- tendence and control--the plan which ready required to be taken by Roman of all would have been the most diffiCatholics in Ireland. Secondly, a pro- cult to effect, though, on every acvision for the Roman Catholie Clergy, count, the most important. With such with a view of gradually attaching views, would he, to use the strong them to the government. Under language of Dr Phillpotts--but not " proper regulations,he wisely con- a whit too strong,"have been either

[ocr errors]

a dupe or an accomplice in the con- himself responsible, in his own individual temptible fraud practised successfully fame, for the results of the policy which on the House of Commons, by the has been pursued. It was only when we bill of 1825 ?" We conclude our re

were given over to divided councils and view of this most admirable pam conflicting principles,--worst of all, when phlet, with a most admirable quota- promising all difference of opinions, by

the wretched system was adopted, of comtion.

acting upon none,-of banishing even the " Whether the practical difficulties at.

name of Ireland from the deliberations of tending the settlement of such a point

our rulersof putting off to a conve. would have been found too great even for

nient season' the most perilous and urMr Pitt to overcome, is a question into gent concerns of that distracted country, which it is not necessary now to enter.

i stultâ dissimulatione, remedia potiùs That these difficulties, great in themselves, malorum, quàm mala, differentes, _ it was have, since his time, become incalculably only then, that we reached the full matugreater, is unhappily too manifest; nor rity of our present evils,-evils so great, does there appear the smallest reason to

that we can neither bear their pressure, nor believe, had he been spared to his country

endure their cure ; but we go on, from day to the present day, that, according to the

to day, from year to year, seeking, by any principles uniformly proclaimed by him,

wretched nostrum the quackery of the age he could now be found among the advo

can furnish, to palliate a corroding plague, cates for concession. It is true, that he

which is fast eating to our very vitals." never would have endured that the mis. We cannot better conclude our rechief should have reached its present hide view of Dr Phillpotts' admirable work, ous magnitude, without any attempt to than by the final sentence of the Archkeep it down; he never would have endu; bishop of Tuam's speech in the House red that the known laws of the land should of Lords. Where, pray, on that ocbe outraged with impunity,--that they, whose duty it was to execute and enforce casion, was the Bishop of Chester? those laws, should not only witness their

Though opposed to the motion of violation with calm complacency, but

the noble lord, and though strenua should, even in their place in Parliament, ously opposed to those who called themselves pronounce the most plausible themselves the advocates of emanciexcuse for past delinquency, and adminis- pation, yet he was a sincere friend to ter the strongest provocative to future ex- emancipation in its true sense. He cesses :--above all, he never would have would emancipate them from the bon endured, that the Majesty of British Le. dage of ignorance-he would emancigislation should be made the scorn and

pate them from gross darknesshe laughing-stock of Irish demagogues--that would emancipate their minds by a lian illegal association, put down by an ex. press statute in one month, should, in

beral and scriptural education ; not the next, rear its brazen front, without

such an education as certain commiseven the decent hypocrisy of a change of sioners had recently recommended to name—should beard Parliament with its the adoption of the legislature-not insolent defiance, should raise a revenue

such an education as would adapt the for the purposes of disaffection_should Scriptures to the passions and prejueven make the shameless but not the im. dices of men not such an educaprudent avowal, (for confidence, in such a as depended upon a corruption of the case, is strength,) that the collection of this text, or upon subtractions from it; he revenue is not merely a contribution for

was no advocate for such an educa. past or present charges, but a bond of tion as that, but he was an advocate union and a pledge of future co-operation, for an education founded upon God's --in the

revolutionary jargon of the day, holy word-he was for an education the people.'* _All this, I repeat, woulă which took that word for its standard not have been endured, had Mr Pitt still -an education which would tend to guided the helm of government-ay, or

correct the superstitions of Ireland, had any one truly British statesman felt and to improve her moral condition.”+

* “ So it has been lately called by Mr Shiel, who adds, ' Every man, who contri. butes the smallest fraction of money, becomes the member of a vast corporation insti. tuted for the liberty of Ireland.'

† Since this article was partly printed, a second edition (as it is called) of the pamphlet alluded to a few pages back, has appeared, with the name of the Reverend Richard Shannon on the title-page.


From her throne of clouds, as Dulness look'd

On her foggy and favour'd nation,
She sleepily nodded her poppy-crown'd head,
And gently waved her sceptre of lead,

în token of approbation.

2. For the north-west wind brought clouds and gloom,

Blue devils on earth, and mists in the air;
Of parliamentary, prose some died,
Some perpetrated suicide,

And her empire flourish'd there.

3. The Goddess look’á with a gracious eye

On her ministers great and small; But most she regarded with tenderness Her darling shrine, the Minerva Press,

In the street of Leadenhall.

This was her sacred haunt, and here

Her name was most adored,
Her chosen here officiated,
And hence her oracles emanated,
And breathed the Goddess in



She pass’d from the east to the west, and paused

In New Burlington street a while,
To inspire a few puffs for Colburn and Co.
And indite some dozen novels or so

In the fashionable style.

The Hall, where sits in sage debate

The council of the nation,
She visited next with much delight;
It happen'd by chance 'twas on the night

Of Huskisson's explanation.

7. There above all her darling Hume

As her Apostle shone; The universal legislator. Financier, and emancipator,

And still in all her own.

8. She enter'd not the Chancery Court,

Because she was going a journey, And when in, how to get out no one can tell ;. “ But Sugden," quoth she, “ will do as well,”

And she left him as her Attorney.

[ocr errors]

with assuring Dr Phillpotts that it is Christian Charity if he can—from no business of his to read hitn a lec- the noble eulogy delivered by one of ture on Christian Charity, and yet- the most eminent churchmen over

one, who was indeed one of the most “ He gives it like a tether, Fu’ lang that day."

eminent statesmen in England.

“ It can hardly, I hope, be necessary “ How far," quoth Pound-text, for me to assure you, in the outset, that I minister of peace is righteously em- feel most strongly the delicate and solemn ployed in raking together the polemie nature of the duty I incur, in thus vencal rubbish of former ages of bigotry turing to comment on the obligation of and ignorance, at the risk of rekind my. Sovereign's Oath. It is a subject, ling the flame of religious discord, which, in itself, and under any circumand with a view to deprive five or six stances, would demand from a religious millions of his Christian brethren of mind, to be treated with the strictest and their natural rights, it is not my pro otherwise possible, in the heat of contro

most scrupulous sincerity. But, if it were vince to decide." And pray, if it be

versy, to forget this duty, the awful event, not his province, whose is it? And which has removed for ever from the scene pray, farther, if it be not, why do it? of our contention the ablest and most disAnd pray, farther, if it be done, why tinguished of all the individuals engaged not "let it be done quickly," instead in it, could hardly fail to recall us to bet. of in a drawling discourse, nearly an ter thoughts, to admonish us, in a voice hour by Shrewsbury, or any other more eloquent even than his own, what well-regulated clock' He himself shadows we are, and what shadows we very soon begins to lose his own


“ Bear with me, I entreat you, for a very temper, and gets, if not mettlesome, yet almost within a hair-stroke of it, in speaking of the eminent person to whom

short space, while I do justice to myself, very nettlesome indeed, with Dr I have here alluded. I have been accused, Phillpotts, on account of his Letters in a late number of the Edinburgh Reto Mr Canning, whom the preacher, view, of treating him with scurrility ;' a widely and deeply read, no doubt, in charge, which, without stooping to confute the history of the whole world, calls it, I fing back on the head of my accuser. “ the ablest statesman of any age Had I ever addressed to Mr Canning any or country!”. “ The good and gene- language, which a public man, on a pub rous of all parties must condemn your

lic question, would have a right to comattempts to raise a clamour against used towards him the smallest portion of

plain of hearing, much more, had I ever such an adversary; and I can scarce

that coarse and unmanly ribaldry, which ly doubt that the death of the distin

this very Review, as often as it suited its guished individual whom they were factious

purposes, delighted to heap upon meant to wound, has since awakened him, I should now feel, what it would recollections in your breast sufficient perhaps be well for my accuser, if he to avenge the wrong."

himself were capable of feeling. As it is, Here we must pull up the preacher no consideration, not even the call of selfon Christian Charity, and insist on defence, shall prevail with me to violate his paying some regard to Christian the Sanctuary of the Tomb, or to recur to Truth. Dr Phillpotts opposed the

any parts of Mr Canning's character or principles advocated by Mr Canning

conduct, but those on which I can offer an

honest, however humble, tribute of respect in Parliament respecting the Catholic claims. He opposed them boldly,

to his memory. His genius, his eloquence,

all the best and noblest endowments of his and like a man, in the spirit of an

highly-gifted mind, devoted by him to the English divine, in the language of an service of his country, during the long English scholar. To the grief of all period of her greatest danger ; he himEngland, George Canning is dead. self ever foremost, in office and out of of. And what are “ the recollections fice, in vindicating the righteousness of which the death of that distinguished her cause, in cheering and sustaining the individual has since awakened in

spirit of her gallant people, and elevating Dr Phillpotts' breast ?" And are they

them to the level of the mighty exigence, such as to "

on which their own freedom and the liber. avenge a wrong," nowhere committed but in the fretful meanwhile

, our Constitution at home from

ties of the world depended ;-protecting, fancy of this very paltry person? Let the wild projects of reckless innovation, Dr Phillpotts speak for himself, and let shaming and silencing, by his unequalled the present preacher learn a lesson of wit, those who were inaccessible to the rea.

" the


soning of his lofty, philosophy :--These prevent their entire degradation : he great deservings, be the judgment of pos-afterwards, at a still more calamitous terity on other matters what it may, will period, yielded to a greater curtailensure to him a high and enduring placement of their power and dignity, for in the proudest record of England's glory. the purpose of preserving the Esta· His saltem accumulem donis, et fungar inani blishment from sinking into Presby- Munere."

terianism." Now go-thou preacher on Christian

6 All this is perfectly true; and in the Charity--go to your pet idol the Edin- necessity for such concessions, sincerely and burgh Review, which is manifestly honestly believed by Charles to exist, and the sole political oracle you have ever in that necessity only, do we find the jusconsulted,-and which, without ac- tification of the actions which it caused. knowledgment, you servilely crawl Whenever such a necessity shall again ocafter on your hands and knees-and cur, it will be for the King of England there study the character of George first to satisfy himself of its existence, and, Canning. There you will see

if he be convinced that it really exists, to ablest statesman of any age or country follow the dictates of the highest species depicted as the basest, meanest, most

of prudence, that master-virtue which ba.

lances conflicting duties, and decides which, profligate of public men. What

in the collision, is to be preferred-decides, collections,” think ye, has “ the death however, not according to the shifting apof that distinguished individual" awa

pearance of temporal expediency, but ackened in the minds of the libellers, cording to the eternal rules of truth and who honoured him with their sincerest justice. Meanwhile, he will not be very abuse when living, and dishonoured ready to give ear to those, who either afhim with their falsest praise when firm or insinuate, that the necessity is come, dead? Are they such as to avenge

or likely to come.

Come when it may, it the wrong? Then must they be bit will, we may be sure, make its presence to ter indeed! But as for you, who be seen and felt ; and even in its approach, preach about Christian Charity, fore it will cast its shadow' long before. sooth, and dare thus to misrepresent pily chosen. It will serve either as an ex

The instance of Charles, however, iş hạpthe bearing, bold and bright and open ample or as a warning :-As an example, as the day, of one of Mr Canning's should the Sovereign wish to fall with dig. most illustrious opponents on one sub- nity, and, in his fall, to avoid making ject alone,-a great question, affecting shipwreck of a good conscience ;'-_-as a the well-being of that Church of which warning, if he choose rather to preserve himhe is himself a shining light and a self, and all the high and sacred interests strong pillar, and which, as long as committed to his charge, from falling at all." it continues to be so illumined and so Dr Milner has, of course, attempte elevated, will defy all assaults, from ed a little casuistry about oaths,whatever quarter they come, secret very much, indeed, in the style of the and insidious, audacious and declared, Surgeon.

« In the first place,” says but phoo--phoo-phoo-itisa waste he, “it is evident that a promissory of our wrath to pour out its vials on oath which, at a certain period, was such a head-for, as we said before good and valid, may cease to be obliis it not--the head of a Croppy? gatory by some material change of cir.

From such “ frivolous" stuff, it is cumstances, either with respect to the a relief to turn even to Dr Milner's object itself, or to any of the parties “Case of Conscience,” which Dr Phill- concerned in it; so that, for example, potts disposes of in a style that would a measure which was originally wise, have astonished the Jesuit. The and beneficial, and desirable, becomes larger portion of the “ Case" is occu- the reverse of all this." pied with an attempt to shew that the Dr Phillpotts rightly observes, that Coronation Oath never prevented our a material change in circumstances is princes from making such alterations here equivalent to an important change in the laws affecting the Church in circumstances; but the c material (which has nothing to do with the change" which the Jesuits intend, as present business) as on the whole they a ground for evacuating the obligathought fit, and in particular, " that

" that 'tion of a lawful oath, is a change in Charles I. gave his consent to the bill the matter, not in the circumstances. for excluding Bishops from sitting in Milner's argument, therefore, comParliament, in order, as it appear- mences either sillily or insidiously. ed at the treaty of Uxbridge, to But hear the two Doctors.

« PreviousContinue »