Page images
PDF
EPUB

vestigations he would say that we could not conclude from the existence of asymmetry in the cranium that there was a corresponding want of symmetry in the brain itself.

Dr. P. AlberT MORROW then read a paper on

AN IMPROVED METHOD IN THE TREATMENT OF CER-
TAIN FORMS OF SKIN AFFECTIONS.

The method referred to was the application of various medicinal substances by means of fixed, adhesive dressings, such as collodion, gelatine, and gutta percha, which has received so much attention from dermatologists during the last one or two years, and the paper was discussed by DRS. BRONSON, J. C. JACKSON, and SHERWELL.

FIRST AID TO THE INJURED.

Before adjournment DR. W. M. CARPENTER presented a resolution, which was adopted, giving the indorsement of the Academy to the Society for Instruction in First Aid to the Injured, which has been in existence for two years in New York, and which now proposes to extend its work to other parts of the country.

MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE COUNTY OF
NEW YORK.
AT a stated meeting of the Society held February
25th DR. WILLIAM S. HALSTED read a paper entitled

THE

EFFECTS OF ADDUCTION AND ABDUCTION ON THE LENGTH OF THE LIMB IN FRACTURES OF THE NECK OF THE FEMUR,

in which he contended that adduction or abduction always formed an important element in the length of the limb in these fractures, and that all statistics of measurements in which they were not taken into consideration were worthless.

The paper was discussed by DRS. A. B. JUDSON and JOHN A. WYETH, both of whom believed it was impossible to secure such exactness of measurement as the writer aimed at, and that the matter was not of as much practical importance as he claimed.

DR. E. C. SPITZKA then read a paper entitled

PATHS OF COÖRDINATION,

based on a case of pure unilateral ataxia without paralysis, which had been under his observation for several years, and in which there was found at the autopsy a secondary degeneration of the stratum intermedium, commencing about the lower third of the pons Varolii, just to the right of the median line, and crossing below the pyramids to the left side, where it extended for some distance down the cord. The symptoms and lesions were described with great minuteness, and the writer believed that the case threw a great deal of light on the tract concerned in the transmission of coordinating power.

The paper was discussed by DR. E. C. SEGUIN, who thought that the results of physiological experiment were somewhat at variance with the conclusions of Dr. Spitzka.

tions. They believed, however, that all abstruse sub-
jects should be avoided, and only those considered
which were of interest to every member of the profes-
sion. Intestinal obstruction was proposed as the first
topic, and they recommended that to each member of
the Society a printed slip should be sent by the secre-
tary, requesting him to send in replies to the following
questions, and to be present at the meeting of March
26th, when the subject would be publicly discussed:
(1.) How many cases of intestinal obstruction have
you treated, and what peculiar symptoms were mani-
fested in each case? (2.) Have you ever performed
an operation for the relief of intestinal obstruction due
to peritoneal adhesions, and if so, what was the result
in each case? (3.) Have you treated any cases of
intestinal obstruction, partial or complete, where the
so-called pathognomonic symptoms, such as stercora-
ceous vomiting and obstinate constipation, were absent?
The recommendation of the committee was adopted.

THE REPORT OF THE DELEGATES TO THE STATE
MEDICAL SOCIETY

was made by their secretary, DR. DANA, who announced
that three of the delegates had been elected permanent
members of the State Society, namely, Drs. Lockrow,
Gibney, and Lewis.

DR. A. JACOBI, from the Committee on Hygiene, moved that the Society should give its official indorsement to THE CHILDREN'S FACTORY BILL, now pending in the Legislature. Adopted.

LICENTIATES IN MIDWIFERY.

The

DR. P. C. COLE read the drafts of two bills which were to be brought before the Legislature, and moved that a resolution be passed to the effect that the Society approved of their general intent and object. first was to incorporate the New York Maternity and School of Midwifery, for the instruction of women in midwifery and the giving of general clinical instruction in this department of medicine. The second was for the State of New York. It provided that no person the purpose of regulating the practice of midwifery in should practice midwifery unless a duly qualified prac titioner of medicine or else a licentiate in midwifery. Licentiates in midwifery were required to receive at least six months' instruction and pass a satisfactory examination; though licenses could be granted also to such practicing midwives as should obtain a certificate from the Board of Managers of the New York Maternity and School of Midwifery. The penalty for infringement of this act, which was to be classed as a misdemeanor, was a fine not to exceed $1000. After some discussion, the whole matter was referred to a at the next meeting of the Society. special committee of five, who were requested to report

A correspondent writes: "One man may steal a horse, while another may not look over a hedge; for example, the city may put heaps of unmixed salt over the numerous air or water covers in the streets (thereby causing holes in the ice, which endanger the lives and limbs of horses and their drivers, in addition to DR. DAVID WEBSTER, chairman of the Committee the other effects of salt), while a railway company on the President's Address, reported that the commit- may not put sand containing a fraction only of salt on tee had decided to recommend the carrying out of the their tracks without lawsuits and fines. Here's offiPresident's suggestion in regard to collective investiga-cial consistency for you!"

COLLECTIVE INVESTIGATIONS.

Recent Literature.

Voice, Song and Speech. A Practical Guide for Singers and Speakers from the Combined View of Vocal Surgeon and Voice Trainer. By LENNOX BROWNE, F. R. C. P., Ed., and EMIL BEHNKE. With numerous Illustrations by Wood Engraving and Photography. 323 pages. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. 1884.

There are few subjects which offer so many conflicting opinions as the questions relating to voice production. The volume before us, besides containing some original matter in regard to the formation of the registers of the voice, presents the views of one school,in our judgment the correct one, and is the joint work of a vocal surgeon and a vocal trainer, whose experience had convinced them "that wrong production of voice or abuse of its functions was the chief cause of most of the cases of vocal failure and even of throat disease," and "that the scarcity of fine voices generally acknowledged to exist was due less to dearth of material than to faults in its cultivation and exercise." The two chief faults are (1) attempting to use the voice with an insufficient amount of air or with imperfect control over the respiration, and (2) an undue forcing of the registers. How to avoid and correct these faults is explained in the chapters on the Hygienic Aspect of the Vocal Apparatus and on Voice Cultivation. These chapters consider in detail all the points bearing upon the care and preservation of the voice, and express the views generally held at present of the true methods for good voice production.

A voice register is defined as "a series of tones produced by the same mechanism," and the five registers into which the authors divide the human voice as a whole they claim are each produced by a distinct muscular mechanism.

The photographs of the larynx taken in the act of singing represent the glottic chink and the position of the vocal bands as they must always exist in the production of the respectively produced vocal tones. It is this portion of the book which relates to the photog raphy of the larynx and soft palate which is of most interest to medical readers. The difficulties of photographing an object in such constant motion and so hidden from view as the larynx have at last been overcome, and the results contained in this volume are the most satisfactory of any yet obtained. One of the points brought out was the difference between the appearance of the arytenoid cartilages as seen in the photograph and that of the conventional image we are accustomed to see in books. This consisted in double outlines in the photograph, which were first considered to be a blemish, but was afterward determined to be due to the perspective view of the interior surfaces of the arytenoid cartilages.

with a powerful light, as was done by Czermak, and then examining with the laryngoscope, it would seem that the vocal bands are in the "thin" quite transparent, while in the "thick" register they are opaque and bulky, "a difference brought about probably by a contraction of the vertical bundles of the thyro-arytenoideus externus." For the production of tones in the "small" register the highest part of the soprano voice-the mechanism consists in the formation of an oval orifice in the front part of the glottis which contracts the more the higher the voice ascends, the vocal ligaments being, in the hinder part, pressed together so tightly that scarcely any trace of a slit remains. No vibrations are here noticeable, while they are, on the contrary, so very marked in the anterior portion as sometimes to blur the outlines of the orifice to a considerable extent." The authors claim to have seen these appearances repeatedly in women as well as in boys. We regret that a photograph of this condition of things was not produced instead of the wellfinished engraving which accompanies the text. Interesting and suggestive as are the authors' remarks in regard to the different ways the vocal bands arrange themselves to produce the different tones, we doubt if they will be accepted until verified by a large number of observations upon different individuals.

The series of photographs of the soft palate show the positions it assumes in the production of tones differing in pitch and quality. It rises with the ascending scale, and the quality of the voice depends upon the degree of tightness with which it closes against the posterior pharyngeal wall. In singing a high note with a pure quality the uvula contracts, the arch between the pillars of the fauces becomes higher and narrower, and the closure of the palate with the back of the pharynx is complete, while on producing the same note with a nasal quality the soft palate is relaxed, thereby allowing the passage of air through the nares, upon which the peculiar quality depends.

We agree with the authors in believing that their results should effectually silence objections to amputating the uvula or removing the tonsils when they interfere with the free action of the soft palate, which, as these photographs clearly demonstrate, is so important for good voice formation.

The book is written in a popular style, and is intended to be a complete manual for singers and speakers. As such we can recommend it as a safe and valuable guide.

A System of Human Anatomy, including its Medical and Surgical Relations. By HARRISON ALLEN, M. D. Section V. Nervous System. Philadelphia: Henry C. Lea's Son & Co. 1883.

This volume confirms the high opinion we have already expressed of this work, and, moreover, strengthTwo photographs taken in the act of singing show ens our conviction that it is suited to the wants of the the positions which the vocal bands assume in the up-graduate rather than of the student of medicine. The per thick and falsetto registers. In the "upper thick" they are approximated and everything is contracted, while in the falsetto the rima glottidis is open and all parts are loose and lax. The appearances in the other registers of the voice are represented by engravings. On ascending the scale and coming to the "thin" register there is nothing in the position of the vocal bands to distinguish the "thick" from the "thin" register. But by illuminating the larynx through the throat

anatomy of the brain is a most difficult matter to present, and we think that the distinguished author has been very successful, always with the reservation implied above, that the reader should be prepared by previous knowledge. It seems to us that the important subject of cerebral localizations in the cortex is rather lightly touched upon. We find nothing whatever of the relations of the convolutions to the skull, a very important chapter, which we hope will have a place in

the final section of the work. The arachnoid is well
described as separating the subdural and the subarach-
noid lymph-spaces. The treatment of the peripheral
nerves is very satisfactory. We are glad to find that
the author recognizes twelve cranial pairs. The re-
marks on each nerve are very interesting, and contain
much that is of practical value. Indeed, they constitute
one of the charms of the book. The illustrations are

good, but we own we should like to see a number of
diagrams, which would help greatly in elucidating the
anatomy of the brain. The volume offers throughout
new instances of the learning and care of the author.
T. D.

Medical and Surgical

THURSDAY, MARCH 6, 1884.

A Journal of Medicine, Surgery, and Allied Sciences, published weekly by HOUGHTON, MIPPLIN AND COMPANY, Boston. Price, 15 cents a number; $5.00 a year, including postage

All communications for the Editors, and all books for review, should be addressed to the Editors of the Boston Medical and Surgical Journal.

Subscriptions received, and single copies always for sale, by the undersigned, to whom remittances by mail should be sent by money-order, draft, or registered letter. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN AND COMPANY, No. 4 PARK STREET, BOSTON, MASS.

THE RELATION OF LABORATORIES TO MED-
ICAL SCIENCE AND MEDICAL EDUCATION.

233

it is this which makes it a vital necessity to educate
medical students to the highest medical level possible,
for they will not rise with the elevation of medical
science, save in rare exceptional cases.
honest about this, and conform our plans to the inev-

itable.

We must be

practice and thorough acquaintance with the progress Let us admit, then, the antagonism between active of medicine, and from this admission let us deduce the duty of educating medical students to the highest limit possible; it then still remains for us to decide how we may best fulfill our acknowledged duty. medicine is a scientific study, and in the methods of Now Journal. chiefly within the last quarter of a century. scientific teaching a vast improvement has taken place been recognized that the sciences deal with the things It has and occurrences by which we are surrounded, that a description of these facts by another does not constionly at first hand. tute real knowledge, but that we know and can know The student must be brought face to face with the phenomena he is to study, he must have scientific law is demonstrated, and accordingly laboratories have been established for the instruction of stua personal acquaintance with the means by which a dents, at least in all the natural sciences. laboratories the student may make acquaintance with In these science at large holds also true of medical science; the facts and phenomena of nature. What is true of THE recent opening of the new biological labora- with the facts of medicine; he works more in the dischief improvement made in our time has been to sethe tory of the Johns Hopkins University and the address secting room and physiological laboratory, and should cure to the student more direct and immediate contact theu delivered by Professor Martin, in which he traces also spend more time at the bedside of the sick. All the rise and development of the laboratory as a revolution in and an aid to study within the past sixty more than value, the imperative necessity of the most years, and delineates somewhat the just expectations thorough and extended clinical instruction possible, and, our readers will doubtless acknowledge the value, or from the expansion of laboratory work in the future, as before said, we have recently had occasion to insist offer an occasion which we must not neglect, to say a few words as to the relation of laboratories to medical student. ical science and medical education, especially as in a diseases that first-hand knowledge which laboratories upon the importance of clinical teaching to the medprevious editorial we dwelt particularly upon the ne- afford of other departments; and, indeed, from this The clinics, with small classes, give of cessity of preserving the relative importance of clin-point of view the distinction commonly made in medical study pursued largely by laboratory methods, by ical schools between laboratory and clinical instrucmethods yielding first-hand and not second-hand knowl- tion cannot be justified, where the term clinical is propedge. If our age in the world's history deserve any ad- of convenience. Nevertheless, for our present purjective at all it surely deserves the adjective progres-pose, we accept the distinction, and wish to say a few erly applied, however natural it appears as a matter sive, and as we are in this age we also must be pro- words concerning the medical laboratories in the regressive, for the part may not rebel against the qual- stricted sense. ity of the whole. Assuredly medicine has progressed, but to be with the time it must continue to advance higher and further. sion depends very largely upon the teaching we get Now our advance as a profeswhile students, for it is a matter of current observation that the active practitioner gradually falls behind as he grows older, his point of view is supplanted by a newer and better one, and he retains his preeminence only on the score of experience, which gives to his opinions a value which nothing else can insure. practitioner may begin fully abreast with the knowlThe edge of his time, freshly imparted to him by specialists, but he cannot remain abreast and practice too, and

30

ble culmination of that immense intellectual revoluThe modern laboratory is a new thing, the invaluadead authority. Indeed, the progress of scientific edution which has nearly freed us from the thraldom of cation may be approximately measured by the number and character of the laboratories at its disposal. There is no more hopeful indication of the gradual elevation of our medical schools than is given by the improvement and multiplication of their laboratories. with characteristic aptness has named the dissecting long time the anthropotomic laboratory, as Dr. Holmes For room, existed alone; all the other departments relied solely upon didactic instruction. Only in anatomy

[ocr errors]

did the students get that direct practical training which was lacking in the other so-called scientific branches of medicine. At present new laboratories are organized from time to time, and especially for chemistry and physiology have many been recently formed. But even the best of our schools are still distant from the goal which must be attained before they can fully respond to the demands of thorough education, because each of the medical sciences needs its own laboratory, and until they are all provided for the goal will remain beyond reach. Anatomy may be granted the first claim, but the other claimants press quickly after it; physiology, chemistry, histology and embryology, pathology, experimental pharmacology, and hygiene, not one of them can do its best without its own large and expensive laboratory. We trust that it cannot be many years before every good medical school in the country will possess laboratories at least for physiology, pathology, and hygiene. For our own part we believe that hygiene is most unfortunately neglected in this country, and that no other addition to the current curriculums of our medical schools is so urgently needed as that of hygiene.

Our medical schools ought, however, to do something more than turn out so many diplomaed students per annum. Those, to be sure, that are carried on as commercial speculations for the financial benefit of the members of the Faculty, cannot be expected to sacrifice their profits to ideal aims, but the endowed schools ought to contribute to the promotion of medical knowledge, and offer ample facilities and hearty encouragement to investigators. In organizing their laboratories these latter schools should bear this higher duty in mind. The improvement of medical practice depends more largely than is perhaps commonly believed upon purely scientific researches, and it is indispensable to wise forethought to have in mind the duty of offering to those young men, who have the inclination and capacity, the opportunity to become investigators after a course of thorough training. This higher duty may be the more readily fulfilled because experience has amply demonstrated that instruction and investigation may be successfully and economically combined in one laboratory.

A good scientific laboratory, properly equipped for its double functions, is a far greater, more difficult, elaborate, and costly enterprise than is generally conceived. The fittings are necessarily numerous, varied, and expensive, even in those departments which need the very least; considerable space is required for the storage of the apparatus, and plenty of space and light for work, we never heard of a laboratory that had too much room! The character and value of the laboratory will, however, be determined more by its officers than by all else, a fact amply exemplified by the first inspirations and the earlier work of the generation of physicists and biologists now passing off the stage. Perhaps we cannot better express what the officers should be and do than by the following extract from a recent editorial of Science upon labora

tories :

"The highest officer must be the responsible direc

tor, -a man of superior ability, extensive attainments, and prolonged experience; one, in short, who has mastered his department of science, knows its possibilities and deficiencies, and is, therefore, capable of judging what work is most feasible and instructive for students, and what problems are best adapted for investigation. It is sheer waste for a man of such high capacity to sacrifice his whole time to the arrangement of apparatus or the preparation of experiments for his lectures or his students; therefore it is desirable, we prefer to say indispensable, that he should have an assistant, preferably a young devotee of science, who will be fitted by his experience as an assistant to ultimately become himself director of a similar laboratory. The third person is the laboratory keeper (diener), who needs must be a man of some mechanical skill, so that the precious instruments may be safely intrusted to his care. He should be something more than a servant, and less than an assistant. A laboratory without this working force cannot do much for the promotion of science, although even more modest ones may be valuable for simple instruction. A firstclass laboratory, and in Germany are many such, has always a larger number of officers. There are few persons among us who appreciate the magnitude of a scientific laboratory; were it otherwise there would not be so many petty substitutes for them."

A laboratory conformed to the high standard set must spend much money; therein lies the difficulty which prevents the immediate establishment of such, for our medical schools are not at all or insufficiently endowed, and have not the means wherewith to create the laboratories, however eagerly they may desire them. If there be any one who wishes to confer a great benefaction upon medicine and mankind by an endowment we should be very glad to see such a gift made for the support of a first-class laboratory at one of the accredited schools already existing.

Medicine, which is exclusively devoted to human welfare, has received in return but little from the generous in comparison with the liberal amounts bestowed for other purposes. The best form of gift would be without restrictions, but if the donor prefers to designate a special object his wisest choice, in our belief, would be, if the sum is very large, to found a hospital under the control of a first-rate school, or, if the sum is smaller, to endow a laboratory of physiology, hygiene, pathology, or histology, or such branch as he may elect, a biological institute being thus ultimately evolved.

PERIODICAL CHANGE OF COLOR OF THE HAIR.

A CURIOUS and apparently unique case of periodical change in the color of the hair is described by Dr. C. Reinhard in the last number of Virchow's Archiv. The subject exhibiting this interesting phenomenon was a female epileptic idiot, thirteen years of age, who was under careful observation at the Dalldorf-Berlin Asylum for two years. Very shortly after the reception of this girl at the asylum it was noticed

that her hair, which was soft and thick, changed its color from time to time from a light yellow to a deep red, and back again. The process, beginning at the end of the hairs, was accomplished pretty rapidly in two or three days, and each change remained seven or eight days. It was noticed that the changes of color were, in a general way, synchronous with the periodical changes in the psychical condition attendant upon the epileptic attacks, the dark color being assumed during the time of excitement and the lighter color during the succeeding period of stupor. These changes occurred in the same hairs, not being dependent upon the growth of new hair. There was no disease of the hair, nor of the scalp other than a slight dryness during the periods of stupor.

The writer, as the result of a careful consideration of this case from different points of view, supported by a thorough microscopical examination of the hair at various periods, and of the skin after death, advances as the most probable explanation of the phenomena described the occurrence of considerable and rapid changes in the amount of air contained in the hair shaft. The light color resulting from the presence of a larger quantity of air veiling the pigment, the darker color returning with the departure of the air. To these results the greater dryness and roughness of the hair, although slight, at certain times probably contributed in some degree by altering the refraction of the light, the drier the hair the lighter the color.

The presence of an abnormal quantity of air in the hair is the explanation offered for those cases in which a permanent and sudden change from dark to gray or white hair is reported, and notwithstanding Hebra's and Kaposi's dissent the occurrence of such is well established by Charcot, Bichat, Lélois, Raymond, and other trustworthy authorities, the last of these recording a case in which, apparently in consequence of severe neuralgia of the head, a patient's hair turned, in five hours, from black to white, passing through an intermediate stage of red. Landois describes one of these cases in Virchow's Archiv, April, 1866, and Wilson credits these sudden changes as authenticated. In these cases of permanent change some other influence than the mere increase of air must come into play, and it is probable that trophic nerve changes contribute to the result in the cases of sudden and permanent change, as also in the singular case of our author, the changes in the first class of cases being carried to an irreparable point.

changes in the hair manifest themselves by a loss of color; (5) the same phenomenon also probably depends upon an abnormal storing up of air, and, as this case shows, may be transitory.

NEW NATIONAL PHARMACOPIA. THE bill providing for the preparation of a new pharmacopoeia, to which we referred in a late issue, attracts no little attention, and the comments are by no means favorable to the introduction of a new standard. The Medical News, of Philadelphia, returns to the charge, however, in a manner which does it little credit. It opens its last editorial on the subject as follows: "The proposition for a national pharmacopoeia appears to meet with general professional commendation, and the only unfavorable criticism which we have seen is based on trivial grounds or on erroneous views of the power of Congress in the premises." As the only favorable comments are found in the News itself and the Journal of the American Medical Association, we fear that the News does not take great pains to learn the views of others. Whether the News acquaints itself with the views of others or is satisfied with its own is a matter of slight importance, but both the manner and the matter of its plea for the bill are noticeable. The editorial mentioned closes as follows: "The authority granted to that body (Congress) does not extend to fixing a standard of drugs and preparations which shall be imperative on the medical and pharmaceutical professions. It can, however, provide a standard for its own departments, and this is all that Mr. Randall's bill proposes to do. If, as is to be expected, that standard should prove free from the imperfections of the existing Pharmacopoeia, the latter would be naturally superseded; but, in any case, it would be for the professions to determine which of the two should be recognized."

That is exactly the reason for the strongest opposition: Congress cannot fix a standard which is imperative on the profession, and as to the departments, we showed in a recent editorial that the existing Pharmacopoeia had been already adopted by the Treasury Department, and by several States as legal standard. Further action of this sort is easy, but in the choice between the professional and the proposed Congressional Pharmacopoeias confusion must inevitably result.

The American Druggist makes the following contribution to history:

The air may penetrate the hair shaft from the atmosphere or may have its origin from the gases present in the blood, and probably may be drawn from both sources. However acceptable these hypotheses may "It is rather remarkable ... that, when Dr. E. R. prove to account for the facts recorded, and in regard to Squibb proposed, a few years since, to change the which it would seem that there can be no question, the method of organizing the Convention so as to place facts themselves may be fairly used to emphasize the the revision of the work, practically, under the aufollowing conclusions: (1) Trophic disturbances in the spices provided for in the above act (Randall's bill), domain of the nerves supplying the scalp may accom- the leading opponents of the plan were Philadelphians, pany other cerebral phenomena; (2) these trophic and that their principal effort was to show that the disturbances may extend even to the hair; (3) such plan already in operation is the one to be preferred. disturbances may, like many other nervous processes, The Convention of 1880 was called, and the subsea periodical character; (4) the attendant quent revision was conducted accordingly; but the

assume

« PreviousContinue »